What if persuasion is the problem, not the solution?


I bet that not even a single Porsche has ever been sold because of the car’s specs.

I mean, of course there are 100 good reasons for why a Porsche is a great car, especially one that’s better than a Nissan or a Mitsubishi.

The only problem is that there are just as many good reasons that prove the opposite.

The good reasons miss the point of buying a Porsche. This ad gets the point.

People who buy a Porsche don’t buy it for the good reasons. They have very personal reasons for doing so. One is that they are now in a position to make their youth dream come true. They can – finally – afford one.

But this isn’t a post about luxury cars. It’s a general principle in communication that JP Morgan captured brilliantly:

“Every man always has two reasons for doing anything: a good reason and the real reason.”

The more a business is trying to prove their idea with good reasons, the more obvious it is that they have no clue about who their customers really are.

And that’s the problem with persuasion.

Persuasion means finding (more and more) good reasons for why I should buy your idea. While the decision hinges on the real reason why I would buy.

Which is why persuasion feels so exhausting on both sides:

You’re trying to influence a different decision than the one I’m trying to make.

The crucial flip is this.

Don’t ask: “How do we explain our product better?”
Ask: “What decision was our customer already trying to make?”

That’s resonance.

And it’s an entirely different conversation.

Keep lighting the path,
Michael

__
You’re reading
What the Best Leaders Say, my reflections on finding words that drive action.
If today’s thought helped you see something in a new light, consider forwarding it to someone who’d appreciate it too. Thanks!

Bringing people together for an event? My keynotes are sharp, respectful, and often unexpectedly personal. They give your audience insights they can act on.

What the Best Leaders Say

Daily insights to help you change minds and drive action. Bi-weekly premium essays that dive deep on how the world’s best leaders communicate.

Read more from What the Best Leaders Say

You’ve built a great place to work. What more do they want? With your bold purpose the company should inspire them. They should appreciate the stability, the freedom, the growth paths. They should see how many extra miles leadership goes to “create belonging.” It’s super unfair, isn’t it? On paper, your team really should love working here. Plus, in the end, it’s also a professional agreement. Which it is. But professional agreements don’t override human nature. The thing is, loyalty is not...

What the Best Leaders Say Issue 8 In leadership circles, the “Patagonia Case Study” has become a bit of a cliché. It’s usually presented as a moral fable: Be virtuous like Yvon, and you will win. A nice sentiment for sure, but utterly useless advice. It suggests that unless you are saving the planet, you cannot replicate their loyalty. And it certainly isn’t helpful if you are selling enterprise software or financial services rather than fleece jackets. But if you strip away the moralizing,...

As you might know, 42 is the answer to the Ultimate Question of Life, The Universe, and Everything, at least according to “The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy.” The only problem is that nobody knows the question. Which couldn’t be more timely. We’re living in a time that’s obsessed with answers. Open any app or tune into any media and you’re bombarded with all kinds of answers on all kinds of questions you never asked. Even worse, when you do ask a question, you’ll get all sorts of answers...